By M. I. Finley

During this examine, the writer demanding situations the present traditions of getting to know and writing approximately old civilizations. He questions, for instance, the distinct prestige accorded to vintage texts, exposes the fake assumptions historians have made, in keeping with restricted details, and provides the failings inherent in traditional factors of the Greek city-state. Emphasizing the necessity to ask the best questions to be able to extend our knowing of existence within the old global, this paintings exhibits how historians may higher take care of the proof that's on hand and gives replacement equipment that may be used to reconstruct historical past.

Show description

Read or Download Ancient History: Evidence and Models PDF

Similar historiography books

Selective Remembrances: Archaeology in the Construction, Commemoration, and Consecration of National Pasts

While political geography adjustments, how do reorganized or newly shaped states justify their rule and create a feeling of shared historical past for his or her humans? usually, the essays in Selective Remembrances show, they flip to archaeology, using the sphere and its findings to advance nationalistic emotions and forge valid precise nationwide identities.

The 10 big lies about America: combating destructive distortions about our nation

“It ain’t lots the issues we don’t comprehend that get us into trouble,nineteenth-century stand-up comedian Josh Billings remarked. “It’s the issues we all know that simply ain’t so. ” during this daring and brilliantly argued ebook, acclaimed writer and talk-radio host Michael Medved zeroes in on ten of the most important fallacies that thousands of american citizens think approximately our country—in spite of incontrovertible proof on the contrary.

Modes of Comparison: Theory and Practice (The Comparative Studies in Society and History Book Series)

In Modes of comparability: thought and perform, the members spotlight how theoretical difficulties have introduced forth new principles on comparability and the way comparability has develop into pivotal within the human sciences. the various chapters during this interdisciplinary quantity replace landmark essays from the magazine Comparative reports in Society and background.

The Philosophy of History

Hegel wrote this vintage as an advent to a chain of lectures at the "philosophy of historical past" — a unique inspiration within the early 19th century. With this paintings, he created the historical past of philosophy as a systematic learn. He finds philosophical conception as neither an twist of fate nor a man-made build, yet as an exemplar of its age, formed via its antecedents and modern conditions, and serving as a version for the longer term.

Extra info for Ancient History: Evidence and Models

Example text

They contributed to a process of professionalization after 1930, which Langlois, Lavisse, Monod and Seignobos had inaugurated in their debates about the status of history as science. Annalistes consolidated their version of professional history in the École Pratique des Hautes Études and the Collège de France. 38 After 1970 this minority of Annaliste institutions would even challenge the desirability of a Sorbonne or Sciences Po. education. Annales historians’ students, too, contributed through their own work to Annales: Institutions and Wider Resonances 35 the dissemination of challenging methodologies throughout France: Maurice Agulhon, Georges Duby, Paul Veyne and Michel Vovelle all taught at the Université d’Aix, Adeline Daumard taught at Amiens and Pierre Lévèque and Guy Bois at Besançon.

Professional guilds and associations mitigated such divisions to varying degrees. 58 A broader perspective brought by these international developments helps to situate the Annales enterprise within its context without detracting from the achievements of its exponents in obtaining an intellectual and institutional niche for their projects. The apparent ineluctability of professionalization and expansion certainly does not render the coming of Annales inevitable, but nor does it alone serve to explain the public prominence also acquired by Annalistes themselves.

Articles in Annales concerning price history and the economic depression of the 1930s based on statistical assessments in the style of Earl J. 72 Financial crisis and economic depression did not, however, determine these developments in isolation, as Johann Heilbron suggested, because the journal continued sociologists’ efforts to make society an historical category. 76 Bloch and Febvre rejected Marxist economic materialism as formulated by philosophers Georges Friedmann and Henri Wallon because they suspected it of reducing phenomena to material causes.

Download PDF sample

Download Ancient History: Evidence and Models by M. I. Finley PDF
Rated 4.83 of 5 – based on 41 votes